A Fair Work Commission decision ordering an unsuccessful unfair dismissal applicant to pay $22,500 in legal costs after finding that his claim had no reasonable prospect of success and that his conduct during proceedings was unreasonable.
The decision highlights the circumstances in which costs may be awarded under ss 400A and 611(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), including unreasonable litigation conduct, false evidence and rejection of reasonable settlement offers.
Recent case
In Fuller v Madison Branson Lawyers Pty Ltd [2026] FWC 4148, Deputy President Bell ordered a former solicitor to pay his previous employer, Madison Branson Lawyers, $22,500 within 28 days.
The solicitor had been dismissed after allegedly misrepresenting his illness or reasons for being absent from work on two days in April 2024, coinciding with the AFL Gather Round games in Adelaide.
During the unfair dismissal proceedings, the Deputy President found that the solicitor had provided false evidence about a telephone consultation with his regular GP that never occurred. His Honour described the conduct as “wilful falsity”.
The solicitor also submitted numerous legal authorities that were fictional or irrelevant to the propositions they purportedly supported. The Deputy President found these had been generated using artificial intelligence and had not been checked or verified.
Costs under the Fair Work Act
Section 611(1) establishes the general rule that each party bears their own costs in Fair Work Commission proceedings. However, s 611(2) provides that the Commission may order a person to pay some or all of another person’s costs where the person made the application, or responded to it, “vexatiously or without reasonable cause”; or “it should have been reasonably apparent” that the application or response “had no reasonable prospect of success”.
Section 400A(1) provides a further basis for costs orders where: “The FWC may make an order for costs against a party … for costs incurred by the other party … if the FWC is satisfied that the first party caused those costs to be incurred because of an unreasonable act or omission … in connection with the conduct or continuation of the matter.”
The Commission found both s 611(2)(a) and (b) were satisfied in this case. It also found the solicitor had acted unreasonably by rejecting two settlement offers, including a $3,000 offer and a subsequent “walk away” offer that expressly warned of a costs application under s 400A.
The Deputy President confirmed that rejecting a reasonable settlement offer can constitute unreasonable conduct, even where the offer does not expressly foreshadow a costs application.
The firm sought $33,570 in counsel’s fees. The Commission assessed recoverable costs at $27,180 before reducing the award to $22,500, taking into account shortcomings in the firm’s own conduct, including delays in briefing counsel and seeking permission to be represented.
The decision also confirmed that recoverable costs are limited to external legal costs and disbursements, rather than a firm’s internal time or lost revenue.
Key takeaways
If you have any questions about unfair dismissal proceedings or costs applications, please contact the Workplace Relations Team:
📞 (02) 6175 5900
📧 workplace@mba.org.au